It has been almost a full year since I last posted. But since nobody reads this blog anyway, that's okay, right? I've been making things and doing things and I hope to share a few pictures of my things before long, but for now I just want to vent a little bit and I really don't think my family needs to hear any more of this particular beef.
I don't think it is a secret that I used to be active in the SCA (Society for Creative Anachronism). My medieval interests have inspired a lot of the material I've shared on this blog already. I don't want to get into a long story, though, just share a few thoughts.
The most recent princess in Oertha (Alaska) put out a request on social media a couple of weeks ago for donations of largesse. That got me thinking and grumbling about how things have changed.
If you are not in the SCA (and actually care about what this is all about), largesse is a term for gifts given within the SCA. When I started, back in the 1990s, how it worked was that if I made something that I wanted to give as a gift, I simply gave it to the person who I wanted to give it to. Elsewhere on this blog is an example of a Viking necklace, based on the one from the Hon hoard, that my wife and I gave to a friend who recognized the work and skill in it. That was largesse back then. We also gave other things to other people, from hand-sewn clothing to beads to armor. It was all largesse, as we used the term back then.
And then I quit doing SCA stuff for a long while, mostly because I have a real life that needs my focus and attention. Raising kids, building a house, going back to school, getting a professional job, all those things that are wonderfully meaningful to me and totally boring for anyone else to read about. And the last few years, I've started paying attention to the SCA again. Which brings us to the recent request for largesse.
It turns out that a new concept of largesse has become the norm. Now, when a person who is good with a stick wins a tournament and becomes royalty (which makes sense only to people who know how the SCA works, so don't ask me to explain it here), that person and his/her consort (the prince and princess, in this case) want to be the ones to give out the gifts. They want to look like generous people, bestowing gifts upon those who they want to recognize or reward.
But, and here's the really odd thing, they don't want to put in any effort to make anything themselves. So they ask everyone else to make a bunch of things they can give away. In other words, largesse has become the province of the people who are good at fighting and functions as a tax on the artisans of the group.
Yeah.
Another digression. There are a lot of things people do in the SCA. But fighting is a bit different from most of the activities. If I play music, perform magic tricks, or tell stories, I'm directly entertaining other people. My fun is for the benefit of others. If I teach people to play a lyre, make a bead, or carve a spoon, my fun again benefits others. If I sew really nice clothes, it at least makes the standard of appearance in the group a bit nicer. And then everyone can benefit from the better looking group and perhaps feel a bit more medieval themselves. But fighting is one of the things that benefits the individual doing it, rather than the group as a whole.
So, my summation is that now the people who do the least to contribute to the enjoyment of the group as a whole want everyone else to make gifts that these fighters can have the fun of giving away. The least creative element wants to get the credit for being generous with the work of the creative people.
Why does this make sense to anyone?
HOW TO INSPIRE ARTISANS LIKE ME AND GET COOL LARGESSE
So, what's a better way to get the largesse? I've already noted that the fighters who win the tournaments generally are not the same as the craftsfolk who make the cool things.
A very authentic way to get the largesse would be to actually go pay money to artisans for their work. If Hrothgar gave a gold arm ring to a warrior he wanted to honor, he would have paid the goldsmith, not said "I want to give some arm rings to people. Please make me a dozen at your own expense. Oh, and deliver them to me by this weekend because I'm in a hurry."
I do acknowledge that in a hobby group we can't really expect the folks playing the part of royalty to spend thousands of dollars on the gifts they want to give. So, that leaves us with three options. First, keep on as it is (which is going to burn out your artisans pretty darned fast - more on burnout shortly). Second, quit giving out so many gifts (but there seems to be a current culture of trying to keep up with the other royals, which includes having a lot of things to give away). And then, my idea for a third route.
If you were to come to me and say "you are a skilled bladesmith and bead maker and I want to give away a bunch of your knives and beads," I'm going to start by telling you a price for my work. Then I'll tell you how long it would take to deliver such an order. (If you're wondering, my simplest blacksmith knives start at $75. A nice hunting knife is anywhere from $300 to $400, depending on details and options. Individual beads hover around the $10 mark.) And then you get sticker shock and revert to option one, expecting me to donate a dozen knives so you can feel special giving them away.
In other words, in my shop, the answer is a resounding NO.
But if you really want the products of my workshop, there is a very good way to get them. This is the third route, that I'm not aware of actually being used. Come talk to me in person. Say something like "you are a talented bladesmith and bead maker. Will you please teach me to make a basic knife or beads I can give away as largesse?" Because you are not an oaf, you'll offer to pay for the material involved. And because you know how to motivate me, you'll also order a pizza during the day so we don't have to stop to cook a meal.
Aha! You just discovered the key to my workshop! You asked me to teach you how to put some of your own skin in the game!
Because posting a Facebook message asking people to make a bunch of gifts for you to give is going to get you absolutely nothing from my workbench. Nothing.
But asking me to teach you so YOU can make things to give will be a very successful way to get my expertise involved.
If you want beads, I'll set you to cranking out basic seed beads. The simple round spacer beads that are not very sexy to make, but are so important to an actual piece. I'll start knocking out bigger focal beads. And at the end of a couple of weekends, you'll have all the beads you wanted for these gifts. You'll have made a whole lot of them, too. And you'll think carefully about how you hand them out because you will know just how much time and effort is involved.
Or if you want a knife to give, I'll teach you do to the rough forging to get the blades forged to shape. Once you've done two or three while I watch, you can bang them out while I do grinding and get them ready for heat treating. See where this is going? You'll do the part that takes more muscle, I'll do the part that takes more finesse, and together we will end up with a bunch of knives. And when you give them away later, you'll know that you put at least an hour into each of them. And you'll know that these are something special. This is important when giving a gift. YOU, the imaginary royalty, will have some skin in the gift game.
If you expect me to set aside my weekend to help you and then tell me you only have two hours for some reason (fighter practice, hangover, other people you want to hang out with), don't even ask in the first place. That's not putting skin in the game. That's insulting me.
BURNOUT
I know this is getting really long, but I want to talk about one more thing. In the SCA, burnout is very common. People burn out on doing the things this group does, then they struggle to put words to their reasons. It took me a lot of years to finally figure it out for myself, but I think this is true of everyone.
People do not burn out on doing the things they love and enjoy.
But people absolutely do burn out on imposed obligations.
Do you see the connection to the expectation of largesse? The artisans who keep making things at their own expense, who pour their work and money into gifts to be given away so the pipe-hitting thug at the top can feel generous... Those artisans are going to be burned out and sick and tired of the SCA a lot faster than if the same thugs offered their muscle and focus to make the gifties, only asking for some tutelage to make it happen.
Does the SCA as a whole really not see how this expectation will ruin the experience for the very best crafters? Or do they really want to drive away the 20% of the group who actually make and do 80% of the things that get made and done? Because those expectations of donated largesse are imposed obligations. And will absolutely burn out the best people.
AND THEN...
Today on Facebook, the princess put out another request. Seems they gave away all the gifties and now want more. Because they like to travel and take the nice things to other places to show off with. As if they somehow deserve the credit for the skill and generosity of the people in Alaska who make these nice things.
Not one word about remuneration. No offer of putting in some effort of their own. Just this:
"His Highness has returned from An Tir well-pleased with the generosity of His subjects, who have allowed Him to give largesse and enhance the reputation of all Oertha. Next week, Her Highness journeys to the far lands of Atlantia, and again your generosity will make her luggage heavier while her heart is happy and proud of Her subjects."
Yep, that's going to get me ready to hand over my work real fast. Sure. Good leadership, there.
No comments:
Post a Comment